A recent legal skirmish in Nanjing, China, has sparked a heated debate about the fairness of public transport fare policies. The crux of the matter? A lawyer, Mr. Xu, is suing Nanjing Metro after being charged a fee for exiting the station just minutes after entering.
According to reports, Mr. Xu entered Longmian Avenue Station on Metro Line 1, but unexpectedly decided to take a ride-hailing service instead. Upon exiting shortly thereafter, he was charged the equivalent of 2 yuan (approximately $0.30 USD). This, he argued, was unreasonable, especially considering that Shanghai Metro offers a 10-minute grace period for same-station exits without charge.
Nanjing Metro, responding to media inquiries, defended its policy. Officials stated that, according to regulations, same-station exits are subject to the minimum fare. For those paying with stored-value cards, the charge amounts to 1.9 yuan. The rationale, they explained, is that the passenger made the choice not to travel, resulting in the fare. Exemptions apply for situations like train malfunctions. The metro authorities also confirmed their legal department would handle any lawsuit.
The news has ignited passionate discussion online. Many users sided with Mr. Xu, calling the metro’s practice “unfair” and questioning the logic of a charge for “not taking the ride”. Some users noted it’s common to need more than five minutes navigating the entry and exit processes, and that the policy lacked a “buffer” period for unforeseen circumstances.
Conversely, others supported the metro’s approach. They argued that waiving fees could incentivize people to use the station for non-travel purposes, disrupting the experience of genuine riders, such as using the station to socialize, or take shelter from the weather. Furthermore, supporters said the metro incurs costs related to security and maintenance regardless of whether a passenger actually travels, making the minimum fee justified.
The dispute raises important questions about the balance between operational costs, public convenience, and user satisfaction when navigating the complexities of modern urban transit systems.
Original article, Author: Tobias. If you wish to reprint this article, please indicate the source:https://aicnbc.com/1021.html
